12 Must-See Reality TV Shows on Prime Video This September 2025

While Amazon Prime Video is known for its high-concept fantasy series like The Rings of Power and insightful comedies such as Fleabag, they have significantly expanded their reality TV offerings in the last few years.

Exciting new titles like 007: The Road to a Million are making their collection more captivating than ever.

Whether you’re into true crime, competitions, crafts, or dating, the Watch With Us team has curated some excellent choices for you on Prime Video.

Explore our picks for September 2025 below.

This James Bond-inspired series features Brian Cox as its ominous host, where aspiring action heroes compete for a million pounds in a globe-trotting quest. Cox stars as “The Controller,” presenting challenges and questions worldwide for the contestants to tackle. Twists, intrigue, gadgets, and daring adventures make this series utterly unmissable.

If you enjoy The Amazing Race, Survivor, or similar challenge-based shows, this cinematic take on reality TV will surely impress you.

Data indicates that the chance of solving any case diminishes by 50% unless a solid lead is discovered within the first 48 hours of a person’s disappearance. In this award-winning reality show, cameras accompany detectives nationwide as they strive to crack murder cases before the trail cools off. Though the series has faced controversy regarding the production’s impact on real investigations, the gripping nature of the show is undeniable.

For true crime enthusiasts, The First 48 offers a captivating exploration of real cases, zeroing in on forensics, interrogations, and more. This is a must-watch if you’re curious about the realities of crime-solving.

The Harrison family — Rick, Corey, and Austin “Chumlee” — have operated the World Famous Gold & Silver Pawn Shop in Las Vegas for years, establishing their expertise. In Pawn Stars, they assess intriguing, rare, and unique historical items brought in by clients, negotiating sales with their characteristic humor and wit. The show provides a fascinating glimpse into history, business tactics, and the unpredictable pawnbroker world.

Rick is recognized for his sharp negotiation skills, Corey blends tradition with a modern view, and Chumlee brings comedic relief, making Pawn Stars an engaging and endearing show. The series also captures the interpersonal dynamics among the cast, introducing a hint of drama to the business.

Judy Sheindlin (a.k.a. Judge Judy) is back in family court — and on our screens — with Judy Justice, a continuation of her daytime series. Despite enhanced production quality, a new set, and a fresh appearance, fans can rest assured — this is the same sharp, candid, and honest judge you’ve cherished for years. Additionally, it’s now a family venture — Judy’s granddaughter, Sarah Rose, steps in as her grandmother’s law clerk. The cases are more intricate and the episodes longer, yet Judy’s signature style remains as she handles these real-life disputes.

Judy Justice offers reality TV fans an enjoyable mix of drama, humor, and insightful commentary from the ever-charming star.

If you adore Say Yes to the Dress but feel disheartened by the thought of beautiful gowns fading in the back of a closet after just one magical day, then Second Chance Dresses is the perfect show for you. In this sadly brief British series, host and Love Island alum Olivia Bowen (née Buckland) selects secondhand wedding dresses for hopeful brides.

What’s especially delightful is that the shoppers engage with the brides selling their dresses, sharing bonds and love stories. It’s an unexpectedly heartfelt experience, and we appreciate how it turns vintage shopping into engaging entertainment.

This moving reality series chronicles a group of adults with Down syndrome as they pursue their dreams and confront challenges. They face their share of drama and hurdles, particularly in the dating realm, but these young adults are truly inspiring in their journey toward independence.

This series provides an authentic portrayal of the lives of individuals with disabilities — showcasing both the challenges and delightful surprises. Prepare to shed a few tears as Rachel Osterbach, Sean McElwee, John Tucker, Steven Clark, Cristina Sanz, Megan Bomgaars, and Elena Ashmore strive to reach life milestones and build a community in their quest for independence.

Clinton Kelly and Stacy London were famed for their candid critiques in What Not to Wear, a well-loved reality series where they transformed individuals nominated by friends and family for their perceived “poor” fashion choices. In Wear Whatever the F You Want, the fashion icons adopt a vastly different approach. Armed with knowledge of their subjects’ dream aesthetics, they assist in curating a wardrobe that allows participants to express their true selves.

Wear Whatever is a warmer, more uplifting show, yet still showcases Kelly and London’s fashion prowess. It provides a positive twist on the makeover narrative, aiming to help the participants become more of themselves, rather than morphing them into a different person.

If you’re considering downsizing, Tiny House Hunters showcases experts leading prospective buyers through the finest tiny homes. From portable micro-houses to rustic mini-cabins, this show illuminates the creative strategies of the tiny house movement that maximizes space while minimizing size.

It’s House Hunters with a downsized twist, and you’ll be amazed at how quickly you become invested in the aspiring homeowners’ aspirations, no matter how “small” they may seem.

The Brent Street Academy is Australia’s premier dance school, but graduation does not guarantee you a role as a dancer. In Dance Life, witness 90 high school seniors relentlessly pursuing their aspirations. The extraordinary talent and commitment on display will astound you, along with the harsh realities of the dance industry.

Competition is fierce in this series, which chronicles a year in the lives of these exceptional students. Dance Life is an ideal show for viewers eager to glimpse behind the curtain of the performing arts world.

The iconic fashion duo Heidi Klum and Tim Gunn, known for their hit series Project Runway, are back with another fashion competition: Making the Cut. In this show, Gunn and Klum assess competitors not only on their design abilities but also on their business acumen. Designers must demonstrate they possess the skills needed to establish a global fashion brand.

The winner receives $1 million to invest in their brand and an opportunity to market their final collection on Amazon, offering a financial and commercial boost. Competitors produce big-budget runway shows and travel to fashion capitals like Paris and Tokyo for challenges. Fans of Making the Cut adore the glamorous venues, high-stakes situations, and the dynamic rapport between Klum and Gunn.

We all love our furry companions, but their quirks can sometimes be annoying or even hazardous. In such cases, it’s wise to seek help from an expert like Cesar Millan, a professional dog trainer renowned for his remarkable talent for rehabilitating unruly and aggressive dogs. Dog Whisperer with Cesar Millan features Millan visiting various locations to assist dog owners in resolving behavioral challenges.

Each episode typically highlights multiple cases, addressing everything from minor disobedience to severe aggression, showcasing Millan’s expertise in understanding and connecting with dogs through what he terms a ‘calm-assertive’ approach. This show is essential viewing for dog owners seeking solutions or those interested in an insightful exploration of canine behavior.

Anyone who has experienced a middle school art class knows that accurately painting portraits is incredibly challenging! This British show invites the finest painters from across the U.K. to not only replicate likenesses but also elevate them creatively. Each season, these talented artists are tasked with creating portraits of celebrity “sitters” such as Sophie Turner, Sir Ian McKellen, Hannah Waddingham, and many others.

Portrait Artist of the Year melds high-stakes competition with artistic exploration. The series captivates viewers with its behind-the-scenes insights into the creative journey and the personal narratives of the artists, enriching the competition. It’s a beautiful reflection on painting as a medium for storytelling and celebrates the arts.