How Many Romantic Interests Does Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw Have?
Justin Hartley’s character Colter in Tracker may be avoiding romance, but it invariably seems to seek him out.
Upon its February 2024 debut, Tracker introduced audiences to Colter, a survivalist who, while a self-proclaimed lone wolf, travels across the nation assisting in finding missing persons and pets. Consider Us completely on board.
Having Hartley, recognized for prior roles in soap operas like Passions and The Young and the Restless, as well as shows like Smallville and This Is Us, certainly added a familiar face for audiences.
However, Hartley emphasized that despite his track record of portraying sought-after characters, viewers shouldn’t expect a fixed romantic subplot for Colter in Tracker.
“The fact that Colter doesn’t have a girlfriend is something I wanted to emphasize,” Hartley, also an executive producer for the show, shared with People in February 2024. “If he had a wife and kids while engaging in all these perilous activities, that would be quite selfish.”
Even though the intention is not to pair Colter romantically, the first two seasons introduced numerous potential love interests. From Fiona Rene’s Reenie to Sofia Pernas’ Billie, here’s a guide to Colter’s romantic possibilities:
Reenie Greene
When season 1 debuted, Reenie was not just presented as Colter’s legal advisor; she also hinted at a complex backstory involving at least one brief encounter, yet their undeniable chemistry was palpable.
To add to the intrigue, Reenie also attracted the attention of Colter’s brother, Russell (Jensen Ackles).
“Deep down, I believe Colter has feelings for Reenie. I genuinely think he has an unconditional love for her,” Rene shared with Us Weekly in November 2024. “He sincerely wants the best for her and to see her happy. In that moment, I think Elliott [Michael Rady] makes her happy, which complicates things for Colter. Does this mean he’s moved on?”
Rene didn’t dismiss the possibility of Reenie reigniting her romance with either Colter or Russell.
“Reenie enjoys the attention; who doesn’t appreciate some validation now and then? We’re all human,” she humorously told Us. “But she seeks a partner who is emotionally, physically, and mentally available, someone with whom communication isn’t a challenge. That’s crucial.”
She continued: “[She desires] someone who prioritizes her — which is a challenge. With Russell and Colter, I’m unsure if Reenie believes they can fulfill that role. [They should] surprise me.”
Justin Hartley’s CBS show Tracker has captivated viewers with its compelling cases and notable guest stars. The series focuses on survivalist Colter (Hartley) as he journeys across the nation assisting law enforcement in solving mysteries.
Billie Matalon
Since reconnecting in season 1, the chemistry between Colter and Pernas’ Billie has captivated audiences. Their dynamic is likely enhanced by the fact that Pernas is Hartley’s real-life spouse, allowing Billie to frequently return as her bond with Colter deepens.
“She’s incredible. If I could choose, I’d want to spend every second with her,” Hartley enthused to Us in July 2024. “It’s amazing to be with someone who means so much to me, whose work I admire so greatly. She enhances our scenes, making my job easier. It’s a joy working alongside her.”
Camille Picket
During the second season’s premiere in October 2024, Colter reignited a relationship with Camille (Floriana Lima), who was connected to an open case he was previously unable to resolve. As Colter searched for Camille’s missing sister, their relationship evolved and faced numerous ups and downs.
“The dynamic has shifted due to a trauma bond. That’s precisely what it is — a trauma bond,” Hartley expressed to TVLine. “It’s heartbreaking, similar to married couples who lose a child and can’t stay together as they see their little one in each other.”
Colter eventually solved the case, revealing that Camille’s sister had been murdered, which provided closure for Camille — effectively pausing their romantic bond for now.
The cast of Tracker has enjoyed more triumphs in their personal lives than their fictional characters. Based on Jeffery Deaver’s novel The Never Game, the series follows survivalist Colter (Justin Hartley) as he aids individuals and law enforcement in solving various mysteries.
Women Involved in His Cases
Tracker depicted Colter engaging with a detective during the series premiere, and that trend has continued. Throughout various cases, he has flirted or shown interest in numerous women he encounters.
Does this suggest Colter might end up with someone unexpected? Likely not.
