Lindsay Hubbard and Danielle Olivera’s Bond on Summer House

At the premiere of In the City on May 19, filmed in September 2025, Lindsay accused Danielle of having a sexual encounter with her ex-fiancé, Carl, shortly after their first breakup in 2019.

Lindsay asserted during the Summer House spinoff that Danielle had undermined her “every year” since the fourth season began in 2019.

“Carl and I attempted to date, but it didn’t work out. He ended things with me,” Lindsay recounted about her 2019 relationship with Carl. “Just a week later, she was giving him a hand job in an Uber.”

Reiterating her claim, Lindsay stated to Kyle, “After Carl and I got engaged, she had a meltdown. Just a week after our breakup, she gave him a hand job in an Uber. That’s really odd.”

During the episode, Danielle disclosed that she and Lindsay hadn’t communicated for four months prior to the filming of In the City in September 2025. She also mentioned that Lindsay “ghosted our friendship” after they met Lindsay’s daughter, Gemma.

In response to Lindsay’s allegations about the sexual act, Danielle’s representative denied the claims, telling Page Six, “The allegation is utterly false and has always been. It’s been very upsetting for Danielle, especially as a woman, to have these unfounded and harmful claims brought up again. It’s unfair to keep subjecting her name and reputation to baseless accusations.”

Danielle also addressed her followers via her Instagram Story, stating, “If this isn’t clarified later, it was a lie then, and it’s a lie now.”

Lindsay fired back at Danielle’s denial in her Instagram Story, saying, “Rewatch season 4 and call me later,” along with an eggplant and a hand emoji.